The Baby Fae Case Essay - 1405 Words

The Baby Fae Case The issues surrounding the Baby Fae case raised some important questions concerning medical ethics. Questions were raised regarding human experimentation (especially experimentation in children), risk/benefit ratio, the quality of informed consent, and surrogate decision-making. Primarily, this case showed that new guidelines were needed to regulate radical procedures that offer little hope and high notoriety and recognition of the physician performing them. Dr. Bailey had been doing extensive research for years on xenografts, or cross-species transplantations, yet none of his animal recipients had survived over 6 months.16 His research was neither governmentally funded nor available for peer-review, and†¦show more content†¦California’s Protection of Human Subjects in Medical Experimentation Act requires that certain criteria be met when a surrogate gives informed consent, and there were weaknesses in the consent procedure provided in Baby Fae’s case. Wer e the surrogate decision makers adequately informed of different options and were they correctly told what the actual chance of success from the xenograft would be? Also, the Secretary of Health and Human Services did not give permission for this unprecedented procedure.16 In this case, medical ethics were deemed less important than the prestige and notoriety gained if the experiment had somehow worked. As soon as news of Baby Fae’s transplantation surfaced, experts in the field expressed sharply polarized opinions regarding Bailey’s professional conduct. Those who endorsed Bailey and his decision believed that the surgery had the potential to prolong Baby Fae’s life until a donor heart could be found. Among these are Michael DeBakey, a pioneer in surgical heart repairs, and William DeVries, the surgeon who performed the first artificial heart implantation.15 However, Bailey did have his fair share of critics. One of the more direct attacks came from John Najarian, head of the Transplant Service at the University of Miami, whoShow MoreRelatedFetal Alcohol Syndrome1466 Words   |  6 Pagespregnancy, there would never be another baby born with Fetal Alcohol Syndrome or Fetal Alcohol Effect† (McCuen 33). This is a very powerful statement. It is also a very simple cure for an alarmingly high birth defect that all women have the power to stop. â€Å"Every year more than 40,000 American children are born with defects because their mother drank alcohol while pregnant â€Å" (McCuen 34). That is 1 to 3 per 1,000 live births (McCuen 31). Many of these cases go undiagnosed â€Å"It is also the numberRead MoreA Very Brief Look at Xenotransplantation 964 Words   |  4 PagesIn the year of 1984 a baby named Stephanie Fae Beauclair was born, better known as Baby Fae. She was suffering from hypoplastic left heart syndrome (HLHS) and she became the first infant subject of a xenotransplant procedure. She received the heart of a baboon and this resulted in her surviving a total of 21 days. The cause of death was heart failure due to rejection of the transplant. The rejection is thought to have been caused by a humoral against the graft, due to Baby Fae’s type O blood creatingRead MoreFetal Alcohol Syndrome Essay1100 Words   |  5 Pagesof a woman drinking alcohol during pregnancy. These defects continue through out the child’s life. One in five hundred children are born with FAS. Your baby is at risk no matter how much liquor you drink. It doesn’t matter if it’s beer, wine, or hard liquor. The chemicals in the liquor quickly pass through into the placenta, which means the baby absorbs as much alcohol as you do. Even a small amount of alcohol is harmful to a developing fetus. A baby’s blood alcohol concentration is higher then anRead More Fetal Alcohol Syndrome Essay3817 Words   |  16 Pagesespecially high-risk women in their childbearing years, need better information about the dangers of drinking during pregnancy. But most health care providers are unfamiliar with and untrained in the issues of substance abuse among pregnant women. FAS/FAE is widely misdiagnosed and under diagnosed and less than 10% of medical schools require students to complete a course on the proper diagnosis and referral of individuals with alcoholism and other drug addictions. Statistics study found that doctorsRead MoreEssay on Characteristics that Accompany Fetal Alcohol Syndrome1764 Words   |  8 Pagesold range(Phelps, 1995). The prevalence of children with FAS is on the rise. More than ever, children are being diagnosed with FAS. Better techniques and knowledge by physicians are accountable for the increase. Physicians are diagnosing more babies today with FAS, because they have more knowledge and resources to evaluate the children at risk. FAS has no racial barriers and has been reported by variable ages from neonatal to young adult (Becker, Warr-Leeper, Leeper, 1990). Estimates in theRead More The Dangers of Alcohol and Alcoholism Essay3323 Words   |  14 Pagesat work, get into accidents, and require emergency health care. The National Institute on Drug Abuse estimate that alcoholics cost American taxpayers sixty-seven billion dollars every year in lawsuits, uninsured patients, law enforcement, and court cases. (Alcoholism Facts) Some believe that alcoholism isn’t a disease because a disease is a disorder of structure or function in a human that produces specific signs or symptoms or that affects a specific location and is not simply a direct result ofRead MoreThe Effects of Alcoholism During Pregnancy Essay1097 Words   |  5 Pagespregnancy. Although many women are aware that heavy drinking during pregnancy can cause birth defects, many do not realize that moderate-or even light-drinking also may harm the fetus. It is vital to protect the rights of the unborn baby simply doing all that we can in ending the alcoholism epidemic during pregnancy. Each person can do this by taking a step toward prohibiting the sale or simply ending the purchase of alcohol. Media reports, documentation, statisticsRead MoreNo Teratogens During Pregancy Essay1169 Words   |  5 Pagesteratogen is any agent or factor that can disrupt the development of an embryo or fetus, which may cause a birth defect or malformation. Whether it is a medication, disease or drug, when the mother is exposed the chances of problems arising with the baby increase. Only ten to fourteen days after conception teratogens can affect the fetus. At that stage in the pregnancy the egg has already been fertilized and attached to the uterus. This is known as the embryonic stage where if health isn’t a priorityRead MoreHow Substance Abuse Negatively Affects The Baby While During1328 Words   |  6 PagesHow substance abuse negatively affects the baby while during a woman’s pregnancy. Many women across the world cause complications to their unborn child when they choose to abuse substance. There are many types of substance abuse such as alcohol, tobacco, and drug abuse. Most likely when women choose to engage in these types of activities it causes harm to the child and birth defects. Long term and short term deformities and conditions are present in the child. Other factors play a part into whyRead MoreFetal Alcohol Syndrome Essay2848 Words   |  12 Pages On any given day in the United States... 10,657 babies are born. (US Census Bureau). Twenty of these babies are born with Fetal Alcohol Syndrome. Twenty may seem as though it is not a lot, but when you compare it to the fact that this number is more than HIV positive, Muscular Dystrophy, Spina Bifida and Down Syndrome combine it creates a whole new parameter. Fetal Alcohol Syndrome is a direct result of a woman’s competed disregard for the fetus. nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;nbsp;Fetal Alcohol Syndrome